Skip to main content
FHAVI

Free tool

Returns are a cost per order, not a percentage

A 20% failure rate sounds like a policy problem. In money, it is a fixed cost added to every order that does arrive — and in cash-on-delivery markets it is often larger than the product cost itself. This puts a number on it.

Read this first

Every return has four costs, and you pay three of them twice

The obvious cost is the refund. The real ones are: the outbound shipping you already spent, the return leg if you cover it, the handling and inspection when it arrives back, and the share of returned items you cannot resell at full price.

A returned order also consumed the same order-processing and support time as a delivered one, and in most stores that is invisible because it is salary rather than a line in a spreadsheet.

Which is why the useful number is not “returns cost X% of revenue” but “each order that arrives carries Y of cost from the ones that do not”.

The tool

Put your numbers in

Defaults are illustrative. Replace them with your own before drawing a conclusion.

Your returns

%

Share of dispatched orders that come back, are refused or are never delivered

$

What the customer paid, including shipping

$

What you pay to send the parcel

$

Zero if the customer pays it

$

Labour and any repackaging per returned item

%

Share of returned items you cannot resell at full price

What it costs

Cost per 100 orders dispatched

$462.00

That is $5.78 added to the cost of every order that does arrive.

Cost per returned order
$23.10
Orders delivered per 100
80

Saves $231.00 per 100 orders dispatched.

Runs in your browser. It excludes chargeback fees, support time, and the revenue you never earned from a customer whose first order failed — all of which make the real figure higher.

Reducing it

Which lever is worth pulling

01

Usually the biggest, usually the cheapest

  1. Address quality — a wrong address is a failed delivery and a second attempt, and it is fixable with a confirmation step.
  2. Order confirmation before dispatch: a scripted call or message in cash-on-delivery markets catches the orders that were never going to be accepted.
  3. Photograph the item before dispatch, so a “not as described” claim has evidence.
  4. Size and material information on the page, since “does not fit” and “not what I expected” are the largest avoidable return reasons.
  5. Carrier choice by route: the cheapest courier is often the most expensive per delivered parcel.
02

Usually smaller than they feel

  1. Restocking fees, which reduce disputes slightly and reduce reorders more.
  2. A stricter returns window, which mostly affects the customers you wanted to keep.
  3. Manual review of every return, which costs more in time than it recovers.

More resources

Keep going

The rest of the library

Every checklist here is free and ungated. The research pages carry the reasoning behind them.

All resources · Research library

Failure rate high enough to eat the margin?

Tell us the rate, the market and the courier. We will tell you which lever we would pull first — and whether the product survives it.

Prefer email? Write to md@fhavi.com