Skip to main content
FHAVI

Free resource

The supplier questions that decide whether ads can work

A supplier that is cheap and slow destroys more ad budget than one that is slightly expensive and reliable. This is the sheet we use before recommending a supplier for a store that will run paid traffic — scored on what affects delivery, not on what affects the unit price.

Read this first

A supplier problem looks like an ads problem

When the cost per purchase looks acceptable and the bank account says otherwise, the cause is often downstream of the ad account: orders that arrive late, items that arrive damaged, or a product that is not what the listing showed. None of those are visible in a campaign dashboard, and all of them show up in refunds, chargebacks and one-star reviews.

Vetting is therefore about the variables you cannot fix later. Once a product is advertised at scale, supplier lead time is your customer's delivery promise, and defect rate is your refund rate.

The sheet

Five groups, scored before you place a real order

01

Sample and quality

Buy before you advertise. Always.

  1. Order a sample as a normal customer would — same channel, same shipping option, no special arrangement.
  2. Compare the sample to the listing photographs. If the images are not the product, the listing is the problem even if the sample is fine.
  3. Check materials, finish and packaging against what the product page will claim.
  4. Ask what happens when an item arrives damaged: replacement, refund, or nothing.
  5. Request the defect rate they will commit to in writing, and ask how it is measured.
02

Lead time

The number that decides whether paid traffic can convert.

  1. Processing time separately from transit time — most suppliers quote only one and mean the other.
  2. Transit time to your actual target market, for the shipping method you will actually use.
  3. Whether a stated estimate is measured or optimistic. Ask for the last 30 days of dispatch-to-delivery, not a policy statement.
  4. Behaviour during a peak: what they do when volume triples, and whether they will say so.
  5. Stock continuity — whether the item you advertise today will still be in stock in three weeks.
03

Commercial terms

  1. Unit price at your expected volume, not at sample volume, in writing.
  2. Who pays return shipping on a defective item, and whether that is refunded or credited.
  3. Payment terms and method — and whether you have any recourse if a shipment never arrives.
  4. Whether they will ship without their own branding, invoices or promotional inserts inside the parcel.
  5. Currency, duties and import costs clarified before the first order, not after the first customs hold.
04

Operational fit

The part that fails when you grow.

  1. How you place orders at volume: manual form, spreadsheet, API, or something that will not scale past 20 a day.
  2. Whether they provide tracking numbers in a consistent format, and how quickly after dispatch.
  3. A named human contact, reachable in your working hours, not only a chat window.
  4. Whether the catalogue data (title, dimensions, weight, materials) is usable or needs rewriting.
  5. Willingness to sign an agreement covering quality, timelines and confidentiality — a supplier who refuses is telling you something.

Deciding

What a pass looks like

05

Green lights

  1. Sample matches the listing, and the listing matches what you will claim on your own site.
  2. Lead time measured, not promised, and consistent across two separate orders.
  3. Defect handling is written down, with who pays for the return.
  4. They will ship unbranded and provide tracking reliably.
  5. They answer a hard question directly — the last 30 days of transit times, not a range.
06

Red lights worth walking away from

  1. Refuses to send a sample, or a “sample” arrives in different packaging and quality from the listing.
  2. Quotes transit time as a range so wide it cannot be a delivery promise.
  3. Cannot say what the defect rate is, or claims zero.
  4. Payment only by an irreversible method with no contract and no named contact.
  5. Pressure to place a large first order for a better price.

Keep going

The rest of the library

Every checklist here is free and ungated. The research pages carry the reasoning behind them.

All resources · Research library

Choosing a product and a supplier at the same time?

Send the product and the two suppliers you are considering. We will tell you which one we would put paid traffic behind, and why.

Prefer email? Write to md@fhavi.com