Skip to main content
FHAVI

Free resource

One decision path, so two customers get the same answer

Refund arguments are rarely about money. They are about inconsistency: two customers with the same problem get different outcomes, one of them tells a payment provider, and the chargeback costs more than the refund would have. A decision tree makes the answer repeatable — and repeatable is what your published policy promised.

First question

What actually arrived

01

Branch one: the item

  1. Arrived as described and on time — no refund obligation. Offer goodwill only as a commercial decision, and record it as such.
  2. Arrived damaged — replacement or full refund, customer's choice. Ask for a photo, but do not require one before acting for low-value items.
  3. Arrived materially different from the listing — full refund. This is the case that becomes a chargeback if handled as a negotiation.
  4. Never arrived — check the carrier status before answering. 'In transit' with a stale scan is not the same as 'not shipped'.
  5. Arrived late — depends on whether you published a delivery window. If you published no window, the customer's expectation was set by you at checkout.

Second question

Who is bearing the cost

02

Branch two: the cause

  1. Our error (wrong item, damaged packing, late dispatch) — we pay return postage and refund in full.
  2. Supplier error — same treatment to the customer; recover from the supplier separately. Never make the customer the negotiator.
  3. Carrier loss — refund or replace, then claim. Holding the customer's money while the claim runs is what triggers disputes.
  4. Customer error (ordered the wrong size, changed their mind) — refund the item, not the original shipping, and only within the published window and condition rules.
  5. Outside the window or the condition rule — decline politely, in writing, quoting the policy line. A documented decline is defensible; a vague one is not.

Timing

What happens after the decision

03

The commitments worth keeping

  1. Acknowledge within one business day, even if the answer is not ready. Silence is what escalates.
  2. State the decision and the reason in the same message — no drip-feeding bad news.
  3. Refund to the original payment method. Store credit offered as the only option is what pushes people to their bank.
  4. Log every refund with its reason code. Six weeks of reason codes tells you whether the problem is the product, the listing, or the courier — and which to fix first.
  5. Where the item is low value, refund without return. The return postage can exceed the margin you are protecting.

Keep going

The rest of the library

Every checklist here is free and ungated. The research pages carry the reasoning behind them.

All resources · Research library

Chargebacks rising?

Send your last ten disputes with their reason codes. We will tell you which branch of the policy is producing them.

Prefer email? Write to md@fhavi.com