Skip to main content
FHAVI

Free resource

The refund policy a reviewer reads, clause by clause

A return policy that says “we accept returns” tells a reviewer nothing. What they check is whether the policy is complete, whether it agrees with the rest of the site, and whether a customer could follow it without emailing you first. This is the skeleton we start from.

Read this first

Four places that must agree

A refund policy is not judged on its own. It is judged against the shipping policy, the checkout page and the product page — and a disagreement between any two of them is read as a misrepresentation risk, even when each page is reasonable in isolation.

The four places: the return window stated in the policy, the window stated anywhere else on the site, the shipping cost shown at checkout versus the shipping policy, and the contact details in the footer versus the ones in the policy and in Merchant Center.

A single number, in a single place, referenced everywhere else — that is the whole discipline.

The skeleton

Fill in the brackets, delete nothing

Copy this into your policy page and replace every bracketed value. Delete a clause only if it genuinely does not apply, and never leave a bracket in place.
RETURNS AND REFUNDS

Returns window
You may return an item within [14 / 30] days of delivery for a refund.
The item must be unused and in its original packaging.

How to start a return
Email [your support address] with your order number and the reason for the return.
We reply within [1] working day with return instructions and an address.

Who pays return shipping
[We pay] return shipping when the item is faulty or not as described.
[The customer pays] return shipping for change-of-mind returns.

Refund method and timing
Refunds are issued to the original payment method within [5] working days of the returned item arriving.
Original shipping costs are [refunded / not refunded] unless the item was faulty.

Damaged or incorrect items
Send a photograph within [48] hours of delivery. We replace or refund in full, including shipping.

Non-returnable items
The following cannot be returned: [list, e.g. pierced jewellery, opened cosmetics, personalised items].

Cancellations
Orders can be cancelled before dispatch for a full refund. Once dispatched, the returns policy applies.

Contact
[Trading name], [postal address], [phone], [email] — these details also appear in our site footer.

Before you publish

Eight checks on the finished page

01

Completeness

  1. A stated return window in days, counted from delivery — not “promptly” or “within reason”.
  2. The condition an item must be in, in plain language.
  3. Who pays return shipping, stated separately for faulty and change-of-mind returns.
  4. How long a refund takes and to which payment method.
  5. What happens for damaged or incorrect items, including who covers shipping.
  6. Any exclusions listed explicitly rather than implied.
02

Consistency

  1. The same window appears on the product page, in the footer summary and in the policy — one number, three places.
  2. Shipping costs and delivery estimates in the policy match what checkout actually charges.
  3. The business name, address and contact details match the footer and Merchant Center exactly.
  4. The policy is linked from the footer of every page, and its title contains the words “Return Policy” or “Refunds”.

Limits

What this is not

This is a structural skeleton, not legal advice. Consumer law varies by market — the EU gives a statutory withdrawal right, the UK has its own distance-selling rules, and the US is state-by-state. If you sell across those markets, the policy has to satisfy each of them, and a lawyer should review it.

What the skeleton does is remove the ambiguity that triggers a review failure. It cannot make an unlawful practice lawful, and it will not help if the store sells goods it is not authorized to sell.

Keep going

The rest of the library

Every checklist here is free and ungated. The research pages carry the reasoning behind them.

All resources · Research library

Policy written and still suspended?

Send the policy page and the suspension wording. We will tell you whether the problem is the policy or something a policy cannot fix.

Prefer email? Write to md@fhavi.com