8 min read
In brief
- The review is not a judgement about how good your policy is. It is a comparison between what your policy says, what checkout charges and what the feed promises — and it fails when those three disagree.
- Two numbers decide most of it: when the order ships, and when it arrives. Merchants state the second and skip the first, which is how a three-to-five day promise becomes a twenty-day delivery.
- A stricter policy that is consistent everywhere passes. A generous policy that contradicts the shipping page, the product page or checkout does not.
What the reviewer is actually comparing
A suspension for misrepresentation is rarely about a policy having the wrong terms. It is about a policy that does not survive comparison with something else on the store, or with what the customer experiences after paying.
Four comparisons happen, and any one of them failing is enough to produce the label.
| The claim | What it is compared against | Fails when |
|---|---|---|
| Delivery time on the shipping page | Transit times in the feed and the handling time in practice | The page says 3–5 days and the feed or the carrier says 12–20 |
| Shipping cost, including any free-shipping threshold | What checkout actually charges | Free shipping over $50 advertised, $4.95 charged at $60 |
| Return window stated in the policy | The window the support team actually honours | Policy says 30 days, support refuses on day 21 |
| Contact details in the policy footer | The business information in Merchant Center | A different address, a disconnected number, or no named entity |
The two numbers nobody separates
Every delivery estimate is made of two periods. Handling time is how long it takes you to dispatch after payment clears. Transit time is how long the carrier takes after that. The customer experiences the sum; most stores advertise only the second.
That is the single most common source of the mismatch, and it is not dishonesty in most cases — it is a merchant who copied a supplier's transit time into a shipping page without adding the two to four days their own order processing takes.
The arithmetic that should appear on the page
Dispatch within 2 business days, then 5–9 business days in transit, is a delivery estimate of 7–11 business days. If you write 5–9 on the site, you have understated every order by the dispatch period, and the customers who complain are the evidence.
- State the handling period separately from the transit period, so a reader can see both.
- Give transit times per destination, not one global number, if they differ.
- Say what happens when a shipment is late — the remedy, not just an apology.
- If you cannot meet a window, change the window. It is the cheapest fix in this entire guide.
The shipping policy: what it must state
- 1
Where you ship, and where you do not
Named countries or regions, not worldwide. A policy that says worldwide while checkout excludes half of Europe is a contradiction a reviewer can see in one click.
- 2
Handling time, in business days
From cleared payment to dispatch. If it varies by product — pre-order, made to order, oversized — say so where the product is, not only in the policy.
- 3
Transit time per destination
Ranges, not a single figure. And state the carrier or service level, because a 5-day estimate means something different for economy versus express.
- 4
Costs and thresholds, exactly as checkout applies them
Flat rate, calculated rate, free over a stated amount, and whether that threshold is before or after tax and discounts. The last detail is where most free-shipping claims break.
- 5
Duties and taxes for cross-border orders
Who pays, and whether they are collected at checkout or on delivery. A customer surprised by a customs bill disputes the charge, and the dispute lands on the merchant record.
- 6
Tracking, and what happens when it fails
Whether tracking is provided, when it is sent, and the remedy if a parcel is lost or stalled — replacement, refund, or investigation window.
The returns policy: what it must state
- The window, in days, counted from delivery rather than from order — and whether it is calendar or business days.
- The condition required for a return: unworn, tags attached, original packaging. If you exclude opened items, say so before purchase, not at the point of refusal.
- Who pays return postage, and whether that cost is deducted from the refund or charged separately.
- Any restocking fee, stated as a percentage or amount, and the situations it applies to.
- How a return is started: the exact route — a form, an email address, a portal — that a customer can actually reach.
- Exclusions, named by category: hygiene items, personalised goods, final-sale lines, hazardous materials.
- Whether exchanges are offered, and whether an exchange resets the return window.
The test is not whether these terms are generous. It is whether a customer reading them before purchase would recognise the process they meet afterwards.
Refunds: the part that gets contradicted
Refund terms are where policies most often disagree with the payment provider. The policy promises five to seven business days; the card network takes up to ten; the customer counts from the day they posted the parcel, not the day you received it.
State the clock precisely: refunds are issued within a stated number of business days of the returned item being received and inspected, and the funds appear according to the payment method's own timeline. Naming both removes the argument before it starts.
| Situation | What the policy should say |
|---|---|
| Cancellation before dispatch | Cancelled and refunded in full, with the cut-off point stated in hours or business days |
| Cancellation after dispatch | Treated as a return, with the same window and the same postage rules |
| Faulty or damaged on arrival | Replacement or full refund including original postage, with the evidence you need — photographs, within a stated period |
| Partly returned order | Whether the free-shipping threshold is recalculated and the difference deducted |
| Item never delivered | The investigation window with the carrier, and what happens at the end of it |
The four places that have to agree
A policy is not a page. It is the same set of facts appearing in four places, and the review compares them.
| Place | What lives there | Common inconsistency |
|---|---|---|
| Policy pages | Handling, transit, returns, refunds, contact | Written once, never updated when the supplier changed |
| Product page | Delivery estimate on the item itself | A different number from the shipping page |
| Checkout | Shipping methods, prices, thresholds, taxes | Free-shipping threshold applied before discount, contradicting the policy |
| Merchant Center feed | Shipping settings and the delivery attributes sent with each item | Set once at onboarding and never reconciled with the site |
One reconciliation, once a month
Place a test order to a real address in each market you sell to. Compare what the confirmation email promises with what the shipping page states. That single check catches the drift that produces most misrepresentation suspensions.
What differs by market
Your policy has to be at least as good as the law where the customer is, and no policy can remove a statutory right. Three things are worth knowing before you write one.
- UK: consumers can cancel most online orders within 14 days of delivery under the Consumer Contracts Regulations, and faulty goods can be rejected within 30 days under the Consumer Rights Act. A 7-day returns policy does not override either.
- EU: the Consumer Rights Directive gives a 14-day withdrawal right from delivery, and the refund must include standard outward postage.
- US: there is no federal right of return, but the FTC's mail order rule requires dispatch within the time you state, or within 30 days if you state nothing — and if you cannot meet it, the customer must be offered a cancellation and refund. That is a delivery promise enforced by law, not just by Google.
If you sell into all three, write the policy to the strictest standard and say which law gives the right. It is shorter than three policies and it cannot contradict any of them.
Six sentences that cause trouble
- Free shipping on all orders — when checkout charges for a remote region or an oversized item.
- Delivery within 3–5 days — when the supplier ships from overseas and the customer waits three weeks.
- Hassle-free returns — with no window, no route and no address anywhere on the site.
- We are not responsible for delays caused by the carrier — true of the carrier, irrelevant to the customer's contract, which is with you.
- All sales final — lawful in narrow cases, and it contradicts the returns page two clicks away.
- Contact us for our returns address — a contact route that produces no reply is worse than a stated address.
If you are fixing this after a suspension
- 1
Do not make the policy more generous than your operation
A 60-day free-returns policy written to look compliant is a promise you will break on the first dispute, and disputes outlive the review.
- 2
Fix reality before the text
If dispatch takes four days, the text says four days. If the supplier cannot do better, the product is the problem, not the policy.
- 3
Correct all four places in the same change
Policy pages, product pages, checkout settings and the feed. Fixing one and leaving three is how a review gets rejected for the same reason twice.
- 4
Then test it with a real order
One order per market, to a real address, compared line by line against what the site promised.
If your account is suspended and the shipping page still promises something the operation cannot deliver, that is where the fix starts — before the appeal, not after it.
