Skip to main content
FHAVI

Research · Operations

Free shipping on a low-AOV store is a margin decision disguised as a marketing one

Free shipping does not cost you the shipping fee. It costs the fee on every order, including the ones that would have converted anyway. Worked through at three order values.

2 min read

In brief

  • The cost of free shipping is the delivery cost multiplied by all orders, not by the incremental orders it produced.
  • At low average order values the fee is often 10–15% of revenue, which is larger than most stores' net margin.
  • A threshold converts it from a fixed cost to a nudge — and the threshold should sit above the current average order value, not below.

The arithmetic

Average orderDelivery costAs share of revenueEffect on a 12% net margin
1,00012012.0%Margin goes to zero
2,0001206.0%Margin halves
5,0001202.4%Absorbable

The table is deliberately blunt. At an average order of 1,000, free shipping consumes an entire 12% net margin, and the store is paying to convert customers it could not afford. The same offer at 5,000 is a rounding error.

This is why free shipping works for high-value catalogues and quietly destroys low-value ones: the mechanic is identical, the ratio is not.

The incremental question

  • Free shipping produces two kinds of order: ones that would have happened anyway, and ones it caused.
  • The cost applies to both; the benefit applies only to the second.
  • The only honest test is a holdout — a period or segment where shipping is charged, compared against one where it is not.
  • Without a holdout, the improvement is usually credited to the offer and to the season it launched in.

What to do instead

  1. 1

    Set a threshold above current AOV

    It nudges basket size instead of subsidising orders that were already going to convert. Place it where the customer must add an item, not where they already are.

  2. 2

    Make delivery cost visible earlier

    A shipping figure on the product page reduces abandonment at checkout more cheaply than absorbing the fee.

  3. 3

    Bundle rather than discount

    Two items at one delivery fee raises AOV without redesigning the price list.

  4. 4

    Recheck the maths quarterly

    Delivery costs move; a threshold set a year ago may now be underwater.

Free shipping is a fixed cost per order dressed as a growth tactic. Run the ratio at your own average order value before you run the promotion.

Questions

Asked about this directly

Does free shipping really increase conversion?
It does, on stores where delivery cost is a meaningful share of the order. The size of the lift is measurable with a holdout and usually smaller than the cost of the subsidy.
Is a threshold better than free shipping for everyone?
For low-AOV catalogues, almost always. It preserves the psychological benefit while concentrating the cost on larger baskets.
What about free shipping in ads?
It is a strong hook, and it commits you on every order the campaign produces. Price the commitment into the campaign's target CPA before launching it.

Keep reading

Other pieces in the library

All research

Numbers first, promises second

Send your store and we will tell you which of these failure modes is already happening — before you pay for a fix.

Prefer email? Write to md@fhavi.com