Skip to main content
FHAVI

Research · Operations

COD versus prepaid: the payment method changes your margin, not just your cash timing

Cash on delivery looks like a conversion win and a finance problem. Worked through line by line, the two methods differ by more than the failed-delivery rate.

2 min read

In brief

  • COD raises conversion and lowers realised revenue: every failed delivery is a sale you booked and never collected.
  • The true cost of COD is the failed-delivery rate times the delivery cost, not the courier fee on successful orders.
  • Prepaid is usually worth a discount to the customer, because it removes a cost you are currently paying invisibly.

The arithmetic, worked

Take an order of 2,000 in local currency. Product cost 700, delivery 120, packaging 30, courier COD fee 25. On a delivered COD order the contribution is 2,000 − 700 − 120 − 30 − 25 = 1,125.

Now assume a failed-delivery rate of 20% — plausible in markets where couriers call ahead and buyers decline. On failed parcels you still pay delivery and packaging outbound, and often a return leg. If the return leg is 100, each failed order costs 250 and collects nothing.

Across ten orders: eight delivered at 1,125 gives 9,000; two failed at −250 each gives −500. Total 8,500, or 850 per order placed. The naive calculation — 1,125 per order — overstates contribution by 24%.

LinePer placed orderNote
Contribution if every order delivered1,125The number most dashboards show
Weighted contribution at 20% failure850What the bank account sees
Cost of the failure risk275Delivery and return legs on declined parcels

What prepaid changes

  • Removes the failure cost entirely: a prepaid order cannot be refused at the door.
  • Adds a payment-processing fee, usually far smaller than the failure cost above.
  • Removes the cash gap: money arrives before the supplier is paid.
  • Lowers conversion — the size of the drop is the thing to measure, not assume.

The discount that pays for itself

If failure risk costs 275 per order placed, a prepaid incentive below that figure is cheaper than the risk it removes — provided it converts orders that would otherwise have been COD, not orders that were already going to be prepaid.

Choosing the mix

  1. 1

    Measure the failure rate by product and area

    It is never one number. A single category or courier zone can carry most of the loss.

  2. 2

    Offer prepaid as the default, COD as the alternative

    Default ordering matters more than the size of the incentive.

  3. 3

    Confirm COD orders by message

    A confirmation step before dispatch removes a large share of refusals at negligible cost.

  4. 4

    Review monthly

    Failure rates move with season, courier and product mix; a mix chosen once goes stale.

COD is not a payment option, it is a risk you are funding. Measure the failure rate, price the risk, and make prepaid the default with an incentive smaller than the cost of the failure it prevents.

Questions

Asked about this directly

Is COD always worse?
No — in markets where buyers do not trust prepayment, COD is the difference between selling and not. The point is to price the risk it carries rather than treat it as free.
How do I know my failure rate?
Delivered orders divided by dispatched orders, from the courier statement, by month. If you only know your refund rate, you do not know your failure rate.
Should the prepaid discount be a percentage or fixed?
Fixed, sized just under the failure cost per order. A percentage scales with order value and overpays on expensive baskets.

Keep reading

Other pieces in the library

All research

Numbers first, promises second

Send your store and we will tell you which of these failure modes is already happening — before you pay for a fix.

Prefer email? Write to md@fhavi.com