2 min read
In brief
- COD raises conversion and lowers realised revenue: every failed delivery is a sale you booked and never collected.
- The true cost of COD is the failed-delivery rate times the delivery cost, not the courier fee on successful orders.
- Prepaid is usually worth a discount to the customer, because it removes a cost you are currently paying invisibly.
The arithmetic, worked
Take an order of 2,000 in local currency. Product cost 700, delivery 120, packaging 30, courier COD fee 25. On a delivered COD order the contribution is 2,000 − 700 − 120 − 30 − 25 = 1,125.
Now assume a failed-delivery rate of 20% — plausible in markets where couriers call ahead and buyers decline. On failed parcels you still pay delivery and packaging outbound, and often a return leg. If the return leg is 100, each failed order costs 250 and collects nothing.
Across ten orders: eight delivered at 1,125 gives 9,000; two failed at −250 each gives −500. Total 8,500, or 850 per order placed. The naive calculation — 1,125 per order — overstates contribution by 24%.
| Line | Per placed order | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Contribution if every order delivered | 1,125 | The number most dashboards show |
| Weighted contribution at 20% failure | 850 | What the bank account sees |
| Cost of the failure risk | 275 | Delivery and return legs on declined parcels |
What prepaid changes
- Removes the failure cost entirely: a prepaid order cannot be refused at the door.
- Adds a payment-processing fee, usually far smaller than the failure cost above.
- Removes the cash gap: money arrives before the supplier is paid.
- Lowers conversion — the size of the drop is the thing to measure, not assume.
The discount that pays for itself
If failure risk costs 275 per order placed, a prepaid incentive below that figure is cheaper than the risk it removes — provided it converts orders that would otherwise have been COD, not orders that were already going to be prepaid.
Choosing the mix
- 1
Measure the failure rate by product and area
It is never one number. A single category or courier zone can carry most of the loss.
- 2
Offer prepaid as the default, COD as the alternative
Default ordering matters more than the size of the incentive.
- 3
Confirm COD orders by message
A confirmation step before dispatch removes a large share of refusals at negligible cost.
- 4
Review monthly
Failure rates move with season, courier and product mix; a mix chosen once goes stale.
COD is not a payment option, it is a risk you are funding. Measure the failure rate, price the risk, and make prepaid the default with an incentive smaller than the cost of the failure it prevents.
